Category Archives: Ukraine 2022

Short notes 4

Viktoria has been working on getting information about her sister, but hasn’t come up with too much as yet. In a previous post I had noted that V found information that Inna had gotten some sort of assistance from a Russian/DPR source but (a) I personally wasn’t sure how accurate that site might have been and (b) that was from the beginning of April, so any aid received would likely have been used up by now. V has been using the contacts she’s been curating on the various Mariupol channels to try to dig up information. She had me look up the street address of Inna’s occasional boyfriend, which is presumably where Inna was staying when she wasn’t at the family apartment block. V tells me that people reported that building as also showing shelling and fire damage.

Viktoria is also formulating plans to get Artem out of Ukraine. V has been chatting with someone she knows who lives in the same area as Artem and Katya 1 and who may be able to get messages to them. Viktoria hopes that Katya would agree and be able to get Artem to Rostov or some other place in Russia, at which point Viktoria would travel to Russia and bring Artem back to the US (presumably under the US “Uniting for Ukraine” program). To say that this is a plan is probably a bit generous. It’s more of a sketchy notion, with a lot of “if’s” and assumptions. If anything comes of it, I’ll let people know.


It sounds like plans for a “victory parade” in Mariupol on May 9 has been cancelled by the occupying forces. Maybe the didn’t think they could get all the rubble and bodies cleaned up in time. Or couldn’t come up with a good propaganda line for why they were marching through a city with damage to 90%+ of the buildings, with half of them beyond repair. (Granted, a lot of the Russian people are ready to believe any of the swill coming from state media, but if the lies are too outrageous, some people are going to start questioning things.) Apparently, believing their own rhetoric, the parade is being cancelled because of a fear from Ukrainian shelling. More likely the shelling of the Azovstal plant wasn’t going to stop and people were either afraid of getting hit, or that it might just look bad (more?) parading through a ruined city that was still under attack. Hard to know what, since rational thought is not involved. (Scared of shelling. In the “DNR” militants canceled the “victory parade” on May 9 – News April 28, 2022 – 0629.com.ua)


The Azov Regiment — having a little time to kill in the Azovstal bunkers, listening to the ongoing barrages — did a little calculating and figure that Russia has spent over a billion dollars (so far) trying to take Mariupol. I don’t know about the accuracy of their numbers, but it seems possible, since they’ve been trying to take the city for two months. During that two months, there has been a lot of artillery, many overflights and bombs, some precision guided missiles, and assorted infantry prowling through the city. That does cost something for sure, so maybe a billion isn’t too far off the mark. If you take into account the other costs that weren’t included in that total — food, fuel, “humanitarian” assistance, digging mass graves, relocating the population by force, etc. — even if the number cited are high, the total cost so far might still be north of a billion. (Russia spends more than $1.1B to destroy Mariupol – Azov Regiment – ukrinform.net)


I’m always a little interested in the animal stories that occasionally appear. There are some nice stories, like those about Patron, the mine-sniffing dog that’s helping in some of the de-occupied areas (Meet Patron, the dog who loves cheese and sniffs out mines in Ukraine – msn.com). Or some of the stories out of Kharkiv or Kyiv about how the animals of their zoo were successfully evacuated (Rescue under fire: Animals evacuated from ecopark near Kyiv – ukrinform.net). On the Mariupol city website was a brief article about the zoo/ecopark in Mariupol. The animals there could not be evacuated, but the staff of the zoo stayed to take care of them (How mariupol zoo survives in the besieged city – VIDEO – News April 27, 2022 – 0629.com.ua). Here’s a version of the story from the AP, along with a video – Mariupol zoo animals caught in crossfire (yahoo.com).

Of course, it’s not all nice or inspiring. I saw a post on Viber today about Black Sea dolphins washing up on shore. They don’t appear to suffer from the “typical” causes of death, such as netting. A marine biologist notes that not only are the dolphins in danger from mines and ship shelling, but the sonar also affects the dolphin’s hearing, causing disorientation. (Off the coast of Odesa region due to the Russian invaders, dolphins are dying en masse – ecologist — tsn.ua)


I’ve mentioned the Russian filtration camps a couple times. DW, a German news service (I was there looking for the zoo story), has an article about what these camps are and how they work (Russia′s humiliating ′filtration′ of civilians fleeing occupied Ukraine | Europe | News and current affairs from around the continent – DW – 28.04.2022).

The neighborhood

Another video that shows the family apartment block. Not much though, just the end. The car is driving down the cross street, coming up on Mira Prospect where the apartments are.

Here’s a little map with the apartment circled and an arrow for the direction of the car. Not shown on the map, but if you followed Mira (“Myru Ave” on the map) to the right, you would come to the theater that was bombed. Walking, about 20 minutes or so, by bus, only about 5 minutes away.

Azovstal

You’ve probably heard the name on the news. Currently it’s the last Ukrainian-controlled area of Mariupol, and it’s been housing the Ukrainian forces as well as a number of civilians who have sheltered with them. Prior to all this — and, really, prior to the Coronavirus pandemic — it was easily the largest employer in the Mariupol area. One of four steel plants located in Mariupol, it was also one of the largest steel plants in Ukraine. (Its parent company, MetInvest, is probably the largest private company in Ukraine.)

It had been operating for decades, and four generations of Viktoria’s family had worked there. Viktoria worked there for 30 years, and before that, her paternal grandmother, V’s father and even her mother for a short time worked at Azovstal. Until about the end of last year, Zhenya worked there as well.

Apparently that place really is massive, both in terms of horizontal area, but also by vertical depth. According to Viktoria, some of the tunnels were open and regularly used by employees to get around the plant. Other parts were a little more restricted. Being part of the electrical crew, Zhenya spent some time in the less public tunnels. A few years back, when there was a lot of metal and wire theft happening at the plant, Zhenya was actually accosted by some of the bandits in the tunnels. And according to Viktoria, her father told her about some of the discussions he’d have at breaks with his coworkers about possible chemical labs and secret development areas the Soviets ran under the plant.

There’s been a lot of discussion about evacuations for the people sheltering at Azovstal, but nothing has come to pass so far. It was widely reported just yesterday that Putin had agreed “in principle” to an Azovstal evacuation with the UN (Putin agrees “in principle” to UN, Red Cross involvement in evacuations from Mariupol – UN chief’s spox (ukrinform.net)), but Russia is out today denying that any such plans are in the works (Russia denies agreement with UN to evacuate civilians from Mariupol’s Azovstal – News April 27, 2022 – 0629.com.ua). Meanwhile, Russian artillery continues to pound the area (Russian forces carried out 35 air strikes on Azovstal in past 24hrs, civilians injured (ukrinform.net)).

Here’s a video of some of the people hiding in the tunnels. You can probably fast-forward over a lot of it; it is mostly static shots of the people talking about the conditions and such. For non-Russian speakers (and yes, most of the people in Mariupol speak Russian — the same people the Russian attacks were supposed to be in support of), just take a look at the conditions. Compared to some other photos and videos I’ve seen, things aren’t as bad, but we still aren’t talking about anything that good either.

While seeing Mariupol getting destroyed has been hard on Viktoria, especially when she gets images of “our” apartment block, watching and reading about the events at Azovstal have been painful as well. She put in 30 years of her life at that factory. She knows and understands what a key part of the city it was, not just for her family, but for many, many of the people and families in Mariupol. I’m sure there were days when she hated going to work, but even on the worst of those days, it’s clear to me that she never would have wished for something like this.

https://www.ukrinform.net/
https://www.ukrinform.net/

Bummer

The US finally came out with their “Uniting for Ukraine” immigration application website today. It’s the “fast-track” immigration program that was promised a while ago to allow about 100,000 Ukrainians to come to the US, provided they have a sponsor to cover their costs. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look like we’ll be able to take advantage of it.

While sponsorship is not a problem, the program requires that refugees coming here have a passport with which to travel. That seems to ignore the reality that a lot of people — including Katya 2 and Vanya — had to leave their homes without such documentation (for any number of reasons). While Katya and Vanya have had international passports issued to them, they aren’t in possession of them and the Ukraine government isn’t able to supply replacements at this time.

At present, it would appear that the Canadian program is going to work better. Their program does account for people not having all their documentation and is willing to work with that. Staying with us would be preferred, but getting them to Western Canada is second best; at least we and/or Viktoria would be able to visit regularly (and a US dollar may go farther in Canada than it does in the US).

Easter 2022

Orthodox Easter, that is.

A little bit of news to relate — Zhenya got some messages from Artem and Katya 1. They’re all still alive and in the Mariupol area. Apparently they are being “processed” by occupation forces, but haven’t been deported to a filtration camp. At least that’s my understanding of Viktoria’s understanding of what she got from Zhenya, so take that third-hand news for what it’s worth. But at least they’re alive and together.

Beyond that, not a lot of positive news out of Mariupol. President Zelinsky made some mention the other day of liberating Mariupol “likely soon,” and while I don’t doubt that he means it, there haven’t been any visible actions. The bombing and shelling of the Azovstal area continues, and the Russians continue to block any attempts at humanitarian evacuation. There had been some arrangements and agreements for Saturday, but the evacuation buses were shot at, the people gathered to evacuate were dispersed from the agreed gathering point*, and later different buses were available for people to go to city in Russia instead. Unfortunately, after weeks of being deprived of the basics, some people are so desperate for food and water that they are willing to do anything.

(* Given the lack of electricity and communications in Mariupol, I’m amazed that word gets around about the evacuations. I feel bad for the people who each time gather their things and get to the meeting point, only to be turned away for whatever reason.)

Viktoria got this picture, below, the other day; it’s of the family apartment block, as seen from the courtyard side of the building. (The other side faces Mira Prospekt, one of main streets through Mariupol.) This shows the third and fourth elevator/entrances for the building. This means that Zhenya’s apartment would be off to the left, just out of frame, and V’s mother’s apartment even further to the left of that. I’m sure whomever took this picture was trying to show the pretty tulips that someone had planted were still there and blooming, despite the destruction around them. Viktoria says that, to her, this looks like a graveyard.

Short notes 3

I’ve added a visual representation of our Ukrainian family under the Family link, in the menu above. Where appropriate, I’ve shown the referenced name followed by their real name. Mostly it’s just all the Katya (which is short for Katheryn and Ekaterina — basically Catherine.) (Viktoria’s family also has a lot of Alexanders; thank goodness I don’t have to show them.)


Supposedly the Russians have taken Mariupol and Putin has called for a halt to any more efforts to take the Azovstal area and plant. Of course, that was all said yesterday, and the shelling continued, so… sure.


The war crimes and attempts to cover them up continue:


A more positive store from the BBC: Mariupol: Driving into the ‘apocalypse’ to save mum and dad – BBC News. For some added context, the events described in the article happened about the same time that Katya 2 and Vanya left Mariupol on foot, walking about 12 miles to a neighboring town.


Although “Mariupol” is being heard a lot these days, if your news is anything like mine, you’ve probably been hearing the name of city pronounced in a few different ways, usually wrong. I think the version I hear the most often is “MARY-opal.” The other night I heard “MARY-you-POLE.” It hurt my ears so much I sent an email to the channel (a local station) and gave them some pronunciation tips (while casually noting that my wife is from there, so, c’mon guys, get it right). Never heard back, but also haven’t heard any recent news about Mariupol on the newscast I typically watch.

In case you were wondering, it’s a four-syllable name — Mar-i-u-pol — with the emphasis on the third syllable. Proper pronunciation would be “mahr-ih-YOU-pull,” but that “ih” isn’t something that shows up much in English. So a close “Western” pronunciation is “mahr-ee-OO-pull,” without too much “ee” coming through. And it’s OK if the second and third syllables end up pushed together; most of the time it does almost sound like the city’s name only has three syllables.

Given everything that’s been happening there — some of which is only starting to be known — it seems only proper to try to pronounce the name correctly.

Found!

Some positive news out of Ukraine: Viktoria was finally able to reach Baba Katya! V had been trying to call her phone every few days, and did occasionally get a blip of response but nothing more substantial. When she tried yesterday (April 18), she was able to connect and they talked for a few minutes. Both Katya and Rodion are doing OK, but they aren’t quite where we thought.

Probably because of a misunderstanding on my or Viktoria’s part, we’d thought that they had left the apartment block base and gotten to a rural area northwest of Mariupol. In fact, they had gone to Oksana’s house in Talakivka (Talakovka in Russian) that had been damaged during the earlier days of the attacks. Talakivka is to the northeast of Mariupol, just past the “suburb” of Sartana. At the beginning of March, it probably seemed like Mariupol was the safer option, given the shelling that had happened in that area, but since attention has been focused on Mariupol for awhile, those outer areas are now relatively calm.

Katya, Rodion, Oksana and her family have been there for about three weeks now, but because they’re still in the Mariupol area, communications have been spotty at best. Being on the Russian-controlled side of the front, Katya was able to go to Donetsk the other day and had been staying with her sister there (Oksana’s mother, I believe) while she did some shopping for supplies and clothes for Rodion.

So that group has now been found, relatively safe and relatively sound. It’s not a great situation, but I’m sure there are alternatives that are far worse. If possible, Katya will try to get in touch with Artem and Katya 1, who aren’t that far away from Talakivka, but getting around is something of a challenge and concern. Still no word on Rodion’s mother Inna.


The New York Times has had a couple things of interest recently. A couple of maps depicting the damage in Mariupol caught my eye the other day. This first map hasn’t been updated for a couple weeks — and the past couple weeks have had some intense attacks — but the extent of the damage to the city is vast.

The family apartment block would be to the left of the leftmost pointer at the bottom.

This other image is a closer look at the damage to the west of the Azovstal area. Zhenya used to live out in this area, and a lot of the drone footage I’ve seen appears to have come from this part of town. This is almost exclusively residential housing, save for the typical shops, schools and places you’d find in any neighborhood.

I thought this video was good, though it’s not from around Mariupol. It was taken in a few of the smaller villages to the west, between Mariupol and Zaporozhia. There are a couple mentions of Vasylivka, which was one of the towns on the evacuation route that Katya 2 and Vanya took.

And lastly, something not from the New York Times, but an composite images posted in one of the channels I’ve been reading.

Aleppo, top, and Mariupol, above

Mariupol video, plus

As noted yesterday, I had a couple videos of Mariupol to share. But first, I invite you to see again what a pleasant place Mariupol was before the Russians came. Here’s a link to some photos on the Mariupol city website; I’d posted in back in 2014, but the link still works. I’d first visited Mariupol in the late-summer/fall of 2011, so I saw many of the same things as are in those images. The apartment where I stayed was right across from that archway — the gateway to the city park — seen in that second image.

This isn’t my video, but since I posted a picture of the Mariupol port, I thought it might be nice to re-post a video of the port from 2016. It’s just advertising, but it shows what the port was (and you can see some of Mariupol in the background).

And now for some less pleasant, but important, views of the city.

From CBS, video of the theater that was bombed. An estimated 900-1000 people had been sheltering here, and about 300 are presumed to have been killed by the bombing.

From Reuters, some scenes of the city, including some views from inside the (less destroyed parts of the ) theater.


Two “pluses” to add. First, we are just about to submit Katya’s and Vanya’s applications for the Canadian emergency travel/visa program. Although is a special program and certain “normal” visa documentation is not being required, it still uses the same online form and process to make the request, so it’s been a bit of a trick to get everything in the right way. Plus the form is in English (and French), and since I’m the only native speaking in the bunch…

Second, I saw someone’s twitter post (embedded somewhere) that put the situation in Ukraine very succinctly:

It's simple: If Russia stops fighting, the war is over. If Ukraine stops fighting, Ukraine is over.

Mariupol

(Sorry for the lack of updates; it’s been a tiring week for some reason.)

While Mariupol has been holding out valiantly for well over a month, I think that it will soon be fully under Russian control. For quite a while, the forces there had been taking advantage of hole in the Russian lines that allowed helicopters to bring supplies to the troops there and remove their wounded. Unfortunately, a couple weeks ago the Russians finally found that hole and closed it up, shooting down a couple helicopters in the process. Without continuing resupply, it’s only a matter of time until the Ukrainian forces are overwhelmed. And the Russians are throwing everything they can at the city to make that happen.

I fully hope and expect that to be a short-lived victory for the Russians, but it will give them one of the propaganda points they’ve been hoping for. Weeks ago, Viktoria had read something (she reads a lot of stuff that I never see) that Putin had been expecting to have a grand parade in Kyiv on May 9. May 9 is Victory Day in Russia and several other former Soviet countries, marking the surrender of Germany in WWII and the occupation of Berlin by Russian forces. The symbolism Putin hoped to have with a parade in Kyiv on that day should be obvious. It looks like they’ve going to try to make do with Mariupol instead.

Parading past all the rubble won’t be a good look, so occupying forces have started coercing remaining civilians to get things cleaned up. This is word (translated below, with light editing) coming from the City Council Telegram channel; I haven’t yet seen the information reported elsewhere:

Does the Gulag live?
Auschwitz - can we repeat it?
Putin, a stale follower of Hitler and Stalin, is realizing his perverted dreams in Mariupol. Genocide, crematoria, ghettos, and now the Gulag. We see it all in the city right now. It became known about the next innovation of the occupiers. Now residents can get food if they pass labor duty at the cleaning of the rubble. The Rashists ["Russian fascists"] are holding the whole of Mariupol hostage, and gradually turning it into one large labor camp.
In 1945, at the cost of tens of millions of lives, Nazism overcame humanity. But this virus of pure evil has been revived in Russia. The world has to stop it before it's too late.

This is what they’re trying to clean up and hide:

four scenes of Mariupol
From mid-March
mariupol port
Part of the port, now under Russian control
train station, before and after
The train station, before and after
An iconic downtown building, before and after
destroyed apartments
An apartment block, just down the road from “our” apartment block.
Katya 2 had worked in one of the street-level shops.

I’ll post a couple videos later, but I’ll finish now with an image that Viktoria received yesterday through one of her chat channels. It’s a picture of the apartment block with her son’s and mother’s apartments. It’s still standing, but as I noted in a previous post, there had been reports of fire. Now we know for sure. I’ve indicated the approximate locations of the two apartments, Zhenya’s apartment on the left, her mother’s on the right.

Myra 110 (Click for a larger view)